Fiction-Net > Book Reviews > Case Histories Book Review Title Author Publisher Case Histories Kate Atkinson Black Swan Fiction-Net Rating Buy It From Amazon UK - Buy This Book Cover Story Cambridge is sweltering, during an unusually hot summer. To Jackson Brodie, former police inspector turned private investigator, the world consists of one accounting sheet - Lost on the left, Found on the right - and the two never seem to balance. Surrounded by death, intrigue and misfortune, his own life haunted by a family tragedy, Jackson attempts to unravel three disparate case histories and begins to realise that in spite of apparent diversity, everything is connected. We Say Case Histories introduces the reader to Jackson Brodie, a brooding ex-police inspector with an ever-increasing workload in his new role as Private Investigator. Given a little more padding than the 'ex-copper turned PI' we've all come across too many times, Jackson Brodie is a rather decent character but he does still feel a little too typical. Having never met a real-life Private Investigator myself, it's difficult to determine whether fictional PI's are a fair reflection on their real-life counterparts but if fictional PI's (and certainly, Mr Brodie) are anything to go by, I'll know one when I see one as they're all so damn alike. Case Histories launches itself off the pages with three really good chapters, introducing us to three separate 'murders' and what we assume will be three sets of main characters. Olivia, a young child, disappears from a tent in her garden. Laura is stabbed to death but is her father, Theo, the real target? Finally, Michelle takes her husband's head off (almost) with an axe. Three seemingly unrelated incidents. The fourth chapter brings Jackson Brodie into the picture and as "everything is connected" (according to the back cover text), we assume the three main cases will be somehow linked and necessary twists and turns apart, it'll all make sense by the end. But it doesn't, really. Given that Jackson Brodie has only three main cases to solve, you'd think it would be relatively 'easy' to follow. Jackson, Victor, Olivia, Julia, Sylvia, Amelia, Theo, Laura, Michelle, Keith, Shirley, Nicola, Deborah, Josie, David, Jennifer, Binky, Marlee, Emma, Stan, Tanya, Lily-Rose - just a selection of the characters you'll need to keep track of if you have any chance of keeping up with Case Histories. It's not that the story is written badly - most of it is interesting and there are some brilliantly flawed characters - it's just put together like a rambling mess and it's near impossible to work out which characters you need to pay attention to. As I read Case Histories, I found myself wanting to write down the names of characters and relationships between them, just so I would have some chance of remembering who is who. New characters are constantly chucked at you throughout the book and it was quite a challenge to remember if I'd already been introduced to them. According to another Fiction-Net reviewer, Kate Atkinson has an "innovative style" and her previous novel Emotionally Weird earned a respectable four-star rating. Observant readers will have already spotted that Case Histories has been awarded a more modest three-star rating. The main problem is that it's just too messy. Events are eventually sort of connected but only because the author has decided to connect them before the book finishes, not apparently out of any logical link. There's a really good story trying to get out here but it's buried under a mountain of junk. Perhaps an editor should have torn the manuscript to pieces and started from scratch, with a more natural flow and with a million less characters. If Case Histories is ever converted to the big screen, Tarantino's skills are going to be needed to make any kind of sense of it. Review by: Rob Cook Buy It From Amazon UK - Buy This Book